Reflections on the Constitution
What various people thought of the Constitution
The Constitution of India has been described, interpreted, and reflected upon by a wide range of voices, from members of the Constituent Assembly and political leaders to administrators and observers in India and beyond. These reflections engage with the Constitution as a transformative document, speaking to its promises of liberty, equality, social justice, and democratic governance. Some voices celebrate its achievements, such as the abolition of untouchability, the guarantee of fundamental rights, and the extension of universal franchise. Others reflect on its responsibilities, reminding us that its success ultimately depends on how it is understood, upheld, and lived by the people.
-
Let us explore how the Constitution of India was perceived, both within the country and across the world.
“Thousands of Indians poured from the hills and from farm lands into the cities last night to celebrate the birth of the independent Indian Republic… Hotels are packed with visitors, and buildings are strung with hundreds of thousands of colored lights as ancient India prepared to become the world’s youngest republic.”
- A Reuters dispatch, reprinted in multiple Commonwealth papers, described the celebrations of republic day
"The Indian Constitution is first and foremost a social document. Themajority of its provisions are either directly aimed at furthering the goals of the social revolution or attempt to foster this revolution by establishingthe conditions necessary for its achievement. Yet despite the permeationof the entire constitution by the aim of national renascence, the core of the commitment to the social revolution lies in Parts III and IV, in the fundamental Rights and in the Directive Principles of State Policy. These are the conscience of the Constitution"
- Grenville Austin, Historian of the Indian Constitution
"The Indian Constitution established a system of Government which is almost quasi-federal, almost devolutionary in character, a unitary State with subsidiary federal features rather than federal States with unitary features." He hailed the founding of the Indian Constitution as ‘the biggest liberal experiment in democratic government’.
- Sir K.C. Wheare, Australian academic
Adult franchise is the most potent instrument for the removal of various disabilities and untouchabilities which disfigured our social structure in the past.
-Kailash Nath Katju, Minister of Home Affairs (1951 – 1955)
“The most noticeable feature of the Constitution is the inclusion of a number of justiciable Fundamental Rights. These will be the sheet-anchor of our liberty and equality in every sphere of life. There will be freedom of speech, freedom of Press, of meeting, and of organization of parties. Untouchability has been completely abolished and its practice in any form penalized. There will be no exclusiveness, no domination by any one and no room for personal or party rule. The rule of law will prevail and will be scrupulously upheld by an independent judiciary.”
-Balasaheb Gangadhar Kher, Former Chief Minister of Bombay State (1947-1952)
“The new Constitution is both a triumph and an opportunity: It represents a triumph of the principles of true democracy, of popular will over the forces of foreign domination, feudal despotisms, religious bigotry and social stagnation. India has emerged as a unified, democratic and secular State based on principles of Liberty, Equality and Social Justice.”
-Balasaheb Gangadhar Kher, Former Chief Minister of Bombay State (1947-1952)
The inauguration of the Republic is an occasion when the people of India should re-affirm their resolve to be a force for world peace.
-Rajagopalachari, last Governor-General of India (1948–1950), Union Minister of Home Affairs (1950 – 1951)
India, happily, is a federal republic, and her Constitution makes provision for its own modification without revolution in the light of experience. Thus we set sail with a fair wind and high hearts into the unknown future.
-Aurthur Moore, managing editor. The Statesman (Calcutta). 1933- 42; president, Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society, 1939-43
"The great thing that this Constitution brings to the notice, not only of this country but of the whole world, is the abolition of untouchability. Untouchability was a slur and a blot on the fair name of India. Great avatars and great saints tried their level best to abolish untouchability, but it was given to this august Assembly and the new Constitution to say in loud terms that no more shall untouchability stay in our country... The Harijans to the last man will uphold the Constitution."
—Shri V. I. Muniswamy Pillai, Member of Constituent Assembly of India
"No Constitution can please the different sections of any country, let alone a country like India, but the overall picture to my mind is very satisfactory and not disappointing. I have great faith that this man-made Constitution will succeed if men will be genuine and generous enough in the working of the Constitution... I have faith enough to say that I am looking forward to a great future for the scheduled tribes as well as for others because it would be for us to make or mar the future of our country, to make or mar the Constitution."
—Shri Jaipal Singh Munda, prominent leader of the Indian tribals and the Jharkhand movement
"I believe, that, by and large, we have hammered out a good Constitution. It will be fallible and it will be necessarily imperfect as it is the product of imperfect human beings, but I believe we have done a good job of work and I believe that this Constitution deserves not only our good wishes but our blessings."
—Mr Frank Anthony, member of the Constituent Assembly of India during 1946–50 and represented the Anglo-Indian community in assembly
"The women of India are happy to step into their rightful heritage of complete equality with men in all spheres of life and activity. I say so because I am convinced that this is no new concept which has been postulated for the purpose of this Constitution, but is an ideal that has long been cherished by India, though tragically debased it in practice. This Constitution affirms that ideal and gives the solemn assurance that the rights of women under law will be wholly honoured in the Indian Republic."
—Begum Aizaz Rasul, Member of Constituent Assembly of India
"Equality of rights is a great thing and it is very good that it has been put into the Constitution. People outside have been saying that India did not give equal rights to her women. Now we can say that when the Indian people themselves framed their Constitution they have given equal rights to women like every other citizen of the country. That in itself is a great achievement and it is going to help our women not only to realize their responsibilities but to come forward and fully shoulder their responsibilities to make India a great country that she had been."



_455.jpg)